There is little demonstration of how this product can be manufactured and assembled. For example, it is not clear how can the two holder rings be attached given that the thickness of each holder rings are less than 5 mm. There is little innovation in this product as holders to stabilise cup has been around for a long time in the market place. Even though the argument is that this product is to be used on boats, there are no clear evidence that this is a consumer need. The report is generally poorly written. The risk and quality analysis is poor and provides no evidence of a detailed and thorough evaluation of the product and its innovation. The CAD drawing is poorly presented and provided a poor impression to assessors from the beginning.